Reps Face Investigation Over Disciplinary Concerns
10th November
Democratic Prospects member
10th November
Democratic Prospects member
On the 21st September, Mike Clancy held a Q&A with reps as part of Prospect's 'Reps' Fortnight'. The session was billed as an opportunity for reps to ask questions of the General Secretary, encouraging reps to submit questions beforehand, and to ask them in the call.
Several reps submitted questions relating to the union's disciplinary process, and use of disciplinary measures against Prospect reps. Ahead of the meeting taking place, reps who asked these questions received the following email from the General Secretary:
"Good morning, this statement is in answer to questions that have been submitted in advance of the reps fortnight call. All of you who are receiving this email have submitted questions which breach the confidentiality of an internal process where the stipulation of retaining confidentiality has been made clear to the participants."
"Furthermore, persistent and co-ordinated challenges to a disciplinary process by those not involved could be viewed as intended to intimidate decision makers into favourable decision making and when made in a public forum as intimidating the complainants into silence and creating a hostile environment for the wider membership in asserting their rights."
It appears that this is a reference to Prospect's suspension of rep, Risa Tan, which was reported by Democratic Prospects the week before (the email later makes reference to the issue being raised on a "public website").
However, reps who made no specific reference to this (or any other) disciplinary case, but merely asked questions about the disciplinary process in general have also reported receiving this email.
This email highlights a recurring flaw in transparency within Prospect, the exact sort of democratic deficit that Democratic Prospects formed to rectify. It invokes 'confidentiality' as a means of preventing and shutting down discussion of genuine issues that affect Prospect members.
It is, of course, correct that there should be privacy around the sensitive information of Prospect members - but Prospect members have reported that disciplinary matters routinely enforce 'confidentiality' clauses that prevent members from talking about their own 'sensitive information', which prevents members from publicly acknowledging their disciplinary cases, even if there are genuine concerns about how the process is being handled.
Enforcing 'confidentiality' in this way acts to prevent members from raising and resolving genuine issues within Prospect. That the email was sent to reps who simply asked questions about the disciplinary process in general, highlights this. The result is that the expectation becomes not that members do not disclose sensitive information about other members without their consent, but that members do not publicly raise any concerns that may challenge a flaw in the way that Prospect is currently operating.
The substantive issues of Risa Tan's disciplinary process are separate from the outcome of the case itself. The core issue is ensuring that Prospect's disciplinary process be conducted fairly and in-line with Prospects' rules: ensuring that the suspension of members is used sparingly, and that members are not suspended without the reason for the suspension being made clear, particularly when those members are elected reps, involved in leading active workplace disputes.
It is deeply ironic that the email talks about intimidating members into silence and creating a hostile environment for the wider membership in asserting their rights - when the issues that reps are being told not to discuss is exactly an issue of members being intimidated into silence. If Prospect members are not confident that the union's disciplinary process is fair, transparent, and unbiased, then how can they engage in free debate without the fear of being subject to a disciplinary process on the basis of their political views?
The email sent to reps goes on to say the following:
"If you sincerely believe that there has been wrongdoing, then the confidential process of the Certification Officer are available to you. Nevertheless, the requirement for confidentiality in the matter is reaffirmed and sets a binding behavioural expectation for all of you."
The Certification Officer is an independent official (i.e. not a Prospect member), originally established in the 1970s, primarily to ensure that only genuine trade unions were registered as trade unions, but later given greatly enhanced powers to police trade unions - with the tory government in 2022 granting the Certification Officer power to initiate investigations into potential rule breaches or statutory violations without needing a formal complaint from a union member, and impose financial penalties on trade unions. Recently, the Certification Officer ruled that Unison had breached its rules when it allowed Ellie Waple, a trans woman, to run for a women’s seat in its National Executive Council elections in May 2025 - effectively overruling Unison policy, set by its members, as a result of a complaint raised by one member supported by a right-wing Christian lawyer who spearheaded legal cases against abortion and trans rights.
Prospect policy, including the way that we handle disciplinary processes, should be decided by Prospect members, not by an external third party that does not represent, and is not accountable to our membership. That our current General Secretary appears to suggest otherwise here is incredibly disconcerting.
At the NEC's committee meeting on the 24th September, the NEC voted to commence a disciplinary investigation into the submission of the questions submitted to the Reps fortnight call. Several Prospect members have been notified that they are within the scope of and subject to that investigation (including one member, whose statement was shared by Democratic Prospects).
The members involved in this investigation include reps who submitted questions about Risa Tan’s suspension, but also includes reps who simply submitted questions about Prospect’s disciplinary process in general. In addition, not every rep who submitted such a question has been included in the investigation. The inconsistency with which reps have been pulled into this investigation calls the impartiality of the investigation into question.
Over a month since reps were notified of this investigation, they have still not been made aware of the allegations that have been made against them (or even if any allegations have been made), and they have not been provided with any timescale for the investigation. The General Secretary has made no comment about how this might
intimidate reps into silence and create a hostile environment for the wider membership in asserting their rights.
Members concerned about the union's response to reps requesting transparency over our disciplinary process, should challenge the NEC on its use of disciplinary action against reps, and write to the NEC to ensure that our disciplinary process is conducted in a fair and transparent manner, and not used as a way to censure or silence members who ask challenging questions of our union's leadership.
Members should also consider the candidates we vote for in future NEC and General Secretary elections. Future candidates should commit to establishing Prospect as a truly democratic union, led by its rank-and file, and to reject dedicating time and resources on pointless internal battles that shut down uncomfortable questions and free debate.